The best Christmas films to buy, ranked by the Spore Score
Buying a Christmas film for yourself or as a present? Here are the best-known Christmas films, ranked by the Spore Score: one number from The Pros and The Punters, with each review site's habits ironed out. Each one links to Amazon UK and Amazon US so you can check today's price.
Links marked Amazon are affiliate links: as an Amazon Associate, Fuzzy Mushroom earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. The ranking is never paid for.
Updated every few hours; last update 19 November 2026.
- It's a Wonderful Life (1946): Spore Score 95, Must-see. The Pros 94 vs The Punters 100. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- Carol (2015): Spore Score 93, Must-see. The Pros 97 vs The Punters 77. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- Miracle on 34th Street (1947): Spore Score 90, Must-see. The Pros 88 vs The Punters 92. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- The Holdovers (2023): Spore Score 90, Must-see. The Pros 90 vs The Punters 89. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- Scrooge (1951): Spore Score 87, Must-see. The Pros 80 vs The Punters 96. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- Die Hard (1988): Spore Score 85, Must-see. The Pros 82 vs The Punters 93. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- A Christmas Story (1983): Spore Score 85, Must-see. The Pros 84 vs The Punters 89. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- Trading Places (1983): Spore Score 79, Worth a watch. The Pros 78 vs The Punters 81. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- Gremlins (1984): Spore Score 78, Worth a watch. The Pros 77 vs The Punters 79. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- Arthur Christmas (2011): Spore Score 78, Worth a watch. The Pros 79 vs The Punters 74. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- Elf (2003): Spore Score 75, Worth a watch. The Pros 75 vs The Punters 74. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992): Spore Score 75, Worth a watch. The Pros 71 vs The Punters 88. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- Batman Returns (1992): Spore Score 75, Worth a watch. The Pros 76 vs The Punters 73. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- Bad Santa (2003): Spore Score 75, Worth a watch. The Pros 76 vs The Punters 71. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- Home Alone (1990): Spore Score 72, Worth a watch. The Pros 68 vs The Punters 88. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- White Christmas (1954): Spore Score 69, Good bet. The Pros 66 vs The Punters 82. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- Love Actually (2003): Spore Score 66, Good bet. The Pros 62 vs The Punters 80. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
- National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation (1989): Spore Score 64, Good bet. The Pros 59 vs The Punters 81. Amazon UK ยท Amazon US
Get the Spore Score the day it lands
The Split by Fuzzy Mushroom: one free email a week with every new Spore Score, the film The Pros and The Punters disagree on most, and what's worth seeing this weekend. Unsubscribe in one tap.
Subscribe free ยท Read this week's issue
Sign-up is handled by beehiiv. See our privacy notice.
Every Christmas film ranked ยท Every A Christmas Carol film ranked ยท Every Home Alone film ranked ยท Christmas 2026 at the cinema