Home › A Christmas Carol films ranked
Every A Christmas Carol film ranked by the Spore Score
Ebenezer, with Johnny Depp as Scrooge, opens on 13 November 2026. Before you go, here's how every Christmas Carol film we score stacks up, from Alastair Sim to the Muppets. The Punters have a soft spot for the Muppets that The Pros don't quite share.
The Spore Score is one number from The Pros and The Punters, with each review site's habits ironed out. Updated every few hours; last update 15 November 2026.
- A Christmas Carol (1938): Spore Score 88, Must-see. The Pros 92 vs The Punters 84. The Pros like it more. Crystal clear
- Scrooge (1951): Spore Score 87, Must-see. The Pros 80 vs The Punters 96. The Punters like it more. Crystal clear
- Scrooge (1970): Spore Score 77, Worth a watch. The Pros 71 vs The Punters 84. The Punters like it more. Mostly clear
- The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992): Spore Score 75, Worth a watch. The Pros 71 vs The Punters 88. The Punters like it more. Mostly clear
- Spirited (2022): Spore Score 63, Good bet. The Pros 62 vs The Punters 67. Crystal clear
- Ebenezer (2026): Spore Score 59, Hit and miss. The Pros 52 vs The Punters 71. The Punters like it more. Fuzzy
- Scrooged (1988): Spore Score 55, Hit and miss. The Pros 51 vs The Punters 70. The Punters like it more. Fuzzy
- Christmas Carol: The Movie (2001): Spore Score 32, Skip it. The Pros 22 vs The Punters 43. The Punters like it more. Mostly clear
Watch them at home
Find it on Amazon UK · Find it on Amazon US
As an Amazon Associate, Fuzzy Mushroom earns from qualifying purchases. Each film page also shows where it's streaming.