Fuzzy Mushroom › Lists › Most overrated films of 2026
The most overrated films of 2026 (according to The Punters)
Critics loved them. Audiences weren't convinced. These are the 20 films of 2026 where The Pros' score beats The Punters' by the widest margin.
Across these 20 films the average gap between the two camps is 30 points. Top of the list: Best of the Best (2026), The Pros 78 vs The Punters 36.
Best of the Best (2026)
This comedy splits the room: The Pros 78 vs The Punters 36. Verdict: worth a watch.
Beast (2026)
34 points apart. The Pros 81, The Punters 47. The Spore Score settles on 65.
Rose of Nevada (2025)
This drama splits the room: The Pros 90 vs The Punters 56. Verdict: must-see.
Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma (2026)
This comedy splits the room: The Pros 94 vs The Punters 60. Verdict: must-see.
The Man I Love (2026)
This one splits the room: The Pros 84 vs The Punters 51. Verdict: worth a watch.
Heads or Tails? (2025)
32 points apart. The Pros 82, The Punters 50. The Spore Score settles on 67.
The Pout-Pout Fish (2026)
32 points apart. The Pros 64, The Punters 32. The Spore Score settles on 49.
Atonement (2026)
30 points apart. The Pros 82, The Punters 52. The Spore Score settles on 74.
Leviticus (2026)
The Pros gave it 89, The Punters only 60: a 29-point gap.
Your Mother Your Mother Your Mother (2026)
29 points apart. The Pros 92, The Punters 63. The Spore Score settles on 86.
Above & Below (2026)
28 points apart. The Pros 51, The Punters 23. The Spore Score settles on 38.
Backrooms (2026)
Spore Score 69, but that hides a 28-point split between The Pros (82) and The Punters (54).
Misty Green (2026)
The Pros gave it 72, The Punters only 44: a 28-point gap.
Bedford Park (2026)
The Pros gave it 92, The Punters only 64: a 28-point gap.
Onslaught (2026)
27 points apart. The Pros 62, The Punters 35. The Spore Score settles on 53.
The Napa Boys (2025)
Spore Score 48, but that hides a 27-point split between The Pros (61) and The Punters (34).
Forbidden Fruits (2026)
Spore Score 59, but that hides a 27-point split between The Pros (65) and The Punters (38).
Is God Is (2026)
Spore Score 81, but that hides a 27-point split between The Pros (90) and The Punters (63).
She Dances (2025)
26 points apart. The Pros 86, The Punters 60. The Spore Score settles on 74.
V/H/S/Halloween (2026)
This horror splits the room: The Pros 76 vs The Punters 50. Verdict: worth a watch.
How this list works
Every number comes from the film's own Fuzzy Mushroom page. The Pros is our combined score from professional reviews; The Punters is our combined score from public ratings. Each review site's habits (some score high, some low) are ironed out first, so the two camps can be compared fairly. The Spore Score sits between them. How the Spore Score works.
Lists rebuild automatically every few hours, so positions move as new reviews and ratings arrive. Last updated 15 November 2026.
Get The Split by Fuzzy Mushroom by email
The films where The Pros and The Punters disagree most, every week, with the Spore Score that settles it. Free, one email a week, unsubscribe in one tap.
Subscribe freeRead this week's issueSign-up is handled by beehiiv. See our privacy notice.
More lists
Most underrated films of 2026 · Critics hated, audiences loved · Biggest splits: November 2026 · Best-rated films out now · All Pros vs Punters splits