Fuzzy Mushroom › Films of 2005 › The Island

The Island (2005) reviews

Spore Score: 56/100 · The Pros: 53 · The Punters: 66 · 3 sources

Is The Island worth watching?

Hit and miss. Spore Score 56/100. The Punters rate it 13 points higher than The Pros.

The Island: cast, director and runtime

Directed by Michael Bay. Starring Ewan McGregor, Scarlett Johansson, Djimon Hounsou and Sean Bean. Runtime: 2h 16m (136 minutes).

About The Island

Genres: Action, Sci-fi/Fantasy.

The Pros vs The Punters on The Island

The Pros give The Island 53 and The Punters give it 66: The Punters rate it 13 points higher. That gap is wider than 69% of the 2,680 2000s films we score. The Spore Score sits between them at 56/100, built from 3 sources and more than 345,000 IMDb ratings.

Taken alone, The Pros' 53 would make it Hit and miss and The Punters' 66 would make it a Good bet. Combined, our verdict is Hit and miss.

By Spore Score, that puts it 157th of 268 films from 2005, 1,563rd of 2,680 from the 2000s and 1,373rd of 2,367 action films that we score.

Site by site, IMDb (The Punters) is the warmest at 6.8/10, which we adjust to 66, and Rotten Tomatoes (The Pros) is the coolest at 40%, adjusted to 48.

The action films with the closest Spore Scores are Nancy Drew (2007, 56), Azumi (2003, 56) and Solomon Kane (2009, 56).

Where the Spore Score comes from

SiteSideSite scoreAdjusted /100
Rotten TomatoesThe Pros40%48
MetacriticThe Pros50/10055
IMDbThe Punters6.8/1066

How we adjust the scores

The Pros' sites said 47, adjusted to 53; The Punters' sites said 68, adjusted to 66. Every review site has habits: some score high, some low, some bunch everything in the middle. We measure each site's habit across thousands of films and iron it out, so a 7/10 from a generous site and a 7/10 from a harsh one aren't treated the same. Then The Pros and The Punters each get one figure, and the Spore Score sits between them. How the Spore Score works.

Where to watch The Island in the US

Rent or buy on Prime Video ↗ Affiliate linkDVD & Blu-ray on Amazon ↗ Affiliate linkWhere to stream (JustWatch) ↗

As an Amazon Associate, Fuzzy Mushroom earns from qualifying purchases. Affiliate links never change a score.

More films like The Island

Best films of 2005 · In UK cinemas this week · Release dates · Out now · Fuzzy Top 100 · How the Spore Score works

Loading…